Sean Mannion's 24-Month Coaching Resume: Breaking Down the Eagles' Gamble at OC

Dan Sileo spent a significant chunk of Friday's National Football Show doing something he does better than almost anyone in sports talk: comparing resumes. His target was new Philadelphia Eagles offensive coordinator Sean Mannion, and the verdict was simple — there isn't much resume to compare.

The Numbers That Matter

Mannion, a former third-round quarterback out of Oregon State, transitioned to coaching in Green Bay under Matt LaFleur. His coaching career spans just 24 months — a timeline Sileo referenced no fewer than two dozen times during the broadcast. He served as an offensive assistant before being elevated to quarterback coach for the 2025 season, his only positional coaching role.

"He's been a coach in the national football league for 24 months. 24 months you have a new offensive coordinator who's never called a play, who's never been in charge of an offense." — Dan Sileo

Sileo examined Jordan Love's 2025 season under Mannion's tutelage as quarterback coach: 66.3% completion rate, 23 touchdowns, six interceptions in 15 games. Respectable numbers — but Sileo was quick to credit play-calling to head coach Matt LaFleur, not Mannion.

"Jordan Love had a good year. Play caller? There is Matt LaFleur. So okay, he works with the quarterbacks. Kevin Patullo worked with the quarterbacks. I'm not seeing the massive upgrade." — Dan Sileo

The Andy Reid Comparison — And Why It Falls Short

Multiple callers and chatters compared Mannion to Andy Reid, who was also a quarterback coach before becoming a head coach. Sileo dismantled the comparison methodically.

"Andy Reid started his coaching in 1982. He ascended to the quarterback coach and assistant coach in 1997 with the Green Bay Packers. Then he became the head coach in '99 and that's where he started calling plays. So it took him roughly 15 years to get that position. This guy's been a coach for 24 months." — Dan Sileo

Sileo also referenced Kellen Moore's path in Dallas, noting Moore spent approximately three years as a coach before Mike McCarthy relinquished play-calling duties — still significantly more than Mannion's timeline.

The McVay Connection

One of the few positives Sileo acknowledged was Mannion's time in systems connected to Sean McVay's coaching tree. Through LaFleur's connection to the Kyle Shanahan-McVay tree — which includes Mike McDaniel, Raheem Morris, and others — Mannion has been exposed to some of the NFL's most innovative offensive minds.

"Him preparing in Sean McVay's system does make me have hope. Other than that, playing time means nothing." — Dan Sileo

However, Sileo was skeptical that any McVay concepts would actually make it into the Eagles' offense, which remains Nick Sirianni's system at its core.

The Photographic Memory Factor

The Eagles have reportedly praised Mannion's photographic memory and described him as someone "born to be a coach." Sileo was unimpressed.

"They say he's got a photographic memory. Great. Glad he can retain things. Most quarterbacks can. There's like nothing you can say about the guy because nobody knows." — Dan Sileo

The Patullo Parallel

Perhaps Sileo's most cutting observation was the comparison to Kevin Patullo, the coordinator Mannion is replacing. Both were elevated from quarterback-adjacent roles. Both lack significant play-calling experience. Sileo challenged his audience directly:

"He's no smarter than Kevin Patullo. What makes you think he's a better coach than Kevin Patullo on January 30th? At least Kevin Patullo has called plays." — Dan Sileo

The Bottom Line

Sileo's position was neither bullish nor bearish — it was honest. He acknowledged Mannion could be the next great offensive mind. He also acknowledged the hire could be catastrophic. What he wouldn't do was pretend there's evidence for either outcome.

"I don't know on January 30th if this guy's going to be good or bad. How could I? I'm going by who he is. You're going by what he may be." — Dan Sileo

After 18 interviews, the Eagles landed on potential over resume. Whether that's visionary or reckless won't be determined until September — and Sileo plans to be watching every snap.