AJ Brown Can't Be Happy: Why the Mannion Hire Should Worry Every Eagles Offensive Weapon

the analysis asked a simple question on Friday's National Football Show — one that cuts to the heart of the Eagles' offensive coordinator hire in a way that scheme analysis and coaching tree maps never will:

"Does Sean Mannion make AJ Brown feel better about coming back and wanting to play here? Absolutely not." — the analysis

It's the question that should keep the Eagles' front office up at night. Not whether Mannion is smart enough. Not whether his photographic memory is real. Not whether the McVay coaching tree connections translate. The question is whether the Eagles' best offensive players — players who have been publicly and privately frustrated with a stagnant passing attack — look at this hire and feel better or worse about their future in Philadelphia.

The AJ Brown Problem

AJ Brown has not been subtle about his frustrations. The Eagles' passing offense ranked as one of the worst in football for the second consecutive season — seventh-worst in 2025, fifth-worst the year before. Brown is a generational talent trapped in an offense that has failed to consistently feature him.

Now imagine you're Brown. You watched the Eagles interview 18 candidates. You heard names floated — maybe Mike McDaniel's guys, maybe someone from Brian Daboll's staff who could move Hurts around and create mismatches. You waited.

And the Eagles hired a quarterback coach with 24 months of NFL coaching experience who has never called a play.

"So you're AJ Brown, new coordinator coming in. You're talking to Mike McDaniel. Guy spreads it around. Jalen Waddle, Tyreek Hill, guys are doing all that. You got Brian Daboll who worked with Josh Allen, gonna move Hurts around, get me open. Then you land on Sean Mannion who's never called a play and has got less experience than Kevin Patullo. If you're AJ Brown and DeVonta Smith and Dallas Goedert — how you feeling?" — the analysis

The Experience Gap

Sileo hammered the comparison between Mannion and the man he's replacing. Kevin Patullo was fired for failing to generate a competent passing attack. Mannion arrives with even less experience than Patullo had when he was hired.

"He's no smarter than Kevin Patullo. What makes you think he's a better coach?" — the analysis

The logic breaks down further when you consider what the Eagles' offensive weapons need. Brown doesn't need a coordinator who can recite formations from memory. He needs someone who can design route concepts that get him the ball in space, create pre-snap confusion for defenses, and build a passing attack that opposing coordinators actually fear. Can Mannion do that? Maybe. But there's zero evidence he can, and Brown knows it.

The Domino Effect

Brown's potential unhappiness isn't just an AJ Brown problem — it's an offense-wide problem. If Brown requests a trade or checks out mentally, the ripple effects are devastating. DeVonta Smith becomes the de facto number one in an already anemic passing attack. Dallas Goedert's role shrinks without a credible deep threat. And Saquon Barkley faces loaded boxes every snap.

Sileo raised this exact scenario: what if Brown leaves and Mannion — a first-time play caller — has to build an offense without the Eagles' best receiving weapon?

"What if he loses AJ and he's a first-time play caller and you don't have AJ Brown in the building? Hey, good luck, man." — the analysis

The Grizzard Safety Valve

The one move that might save the Eagles from a player revolt is Josh Grizzard. The former Bucs OC has actual play-calling experience, worked under Mike McDaniel's scheme in Miami, and was considered for OC positions by multiple teams. Sileo sees Grizzard as the real hire — the coordinator in all but name.

"It feels almost like the real guy they wanted to hire was Josh Grizzard for the coordinating job. It's kind of like a seat belt or safety belt kind of hire." — the analysis

If Mannion struggles early, Grizzard provides an immediate fallback. That might be enough to keep Brown and the other skill players invested — for now.

The Bottom Line

Sileo's take isn't that Mannion will fail. It's that the hire does nothing to address the legitimate frustrations of the Eagles' best players. Brown wanted answers. Smith wanted creativity. The offensive line wanted stability after the Stoutland debacle. Instead, they got a 24-month coach with a photographic memory and a lot of potential.

Potential is a wonderful word. But as Sileo noted, potential means you haven't done it yet. And for players like AJ Brown, who are running out of patience, "yet" might be too late.