Breaking Down the Sean Mannion Hire: What a 33-Year-Old First-Time OC Means for the Eagles

The Most Unconventional Hire in Recent NFL History

The Philadelphia Eagles have officially hired Sean Mannion as their offensive coordinator, ending a 17-day search with the most unconventional choice imaginable. At 33 years old with just two years of coaching experience and zero play-calling experience at any level, Mannion's hiring is virtually unprecedented in the modern NFL.

As Birds 365 co-host the host put it on Friday's show: "I'm stunned they hired Sean Mannion with two years of experience to be an offensive coordinator. It's just not done."

Who Is Sean Mannion?

Mannion's football resume is more extensive than his coaching resume suggests. Born in San Jose, California, the 6'6" quarterback was a record-setter at Oregon State, throwing for 13,600 yards and 83 touchdowns to become the Pac-12's all-time passing yards leader. He was selected by the St. Louis Rams in the third round of the 2015 NFL Draft (89th overall).

Over eight NFL seasons (2015-2023), Mannion played for the Rams, Vikings, and Seahawks. He was never a starter — typically serving as a third-string quarterback or practice squad player — but those years weren't wasted. As Kaden Steele of NJ.com noted on Friday's show, backup quarterbacks in that role "are extensions of coaching staffs." Mannion spent most of his playing career thinking like a coach, assisting in meeting rooms, and absorbing offensive schemes from some of the game's brightest minds.

His coaching rolodex reads like a who's who of offensive football: Sean McVay, Kevin O'Connell, Kevin Stefanski, Klint Kubiak, and Matt LaFleur. LaFleur hired Mannion as a Packers offensive assistant in 2024, then promoted him to quarterbacks coach the following season.

The Case For Mannion

Every coach who has worked with Mannion speaks about him as a future head coach. LaFleur praised him for going "above and beyond the call of duty." McVay, O'Connell, and LaFleur have all called him a future head coach at one point or another.

There's also the Malik Willis factor. When the Packers lost Jordan Love to injury last season, the coaching staff — with Mannion as QB coach — adapted the offense beautifully for Willis. In one start against Baltimore, Willis went 18-of-21 for 288 yards. The Packers didn't ask Willis to be Jordan Love. They changed the scheme to emphasize Willis's strengths, including his legs and efficiency. That's exactly the kind of adaptability the Eagles need with Jalen Hurts.

the comparison was made Mannion to Kellen Moore — both highly accomplished college quarterbacks who transitioned to coaching. But he noted that Moore had six years as an OC before arriving in Philadelphia, giving him far more cachet to weather criticism and drown out noise from players and media alike.

The Case Against

The concerns are obvious and significant. Mannion wasn't just inexperienced as a play-caller — he was multiple levels removed from play-calling in Green Bay. The Packers' hierarchy had LaFleur calling plays, offensive coordinator Adam Stenavich below him, passing game coordinator Jason Vrable below that, and a game management specialist Connor Lewis. Mannion was, at best, fourth or fifth on the pecking order.

As it was emphasized, Mannion is "a human being" and will inevitably have growing pains. "You never do something before... you're not going to step into a job and just have all the answers on day one," it was noted. The question is whether Philadelphia — a city that has historically shown very little patience with offensive coordinators — will give him the time to learn.

the expectation is clear the answer: "No. They won't."

The David Blough Comparison

McMullen pointed to one active parallel: Washington's hiring of David Blough as their offensive coordinator. Blough was playing as recently as 2023, served as an assistant quarterbacks coach (not even the full QB coach), and was promoted to OC — an even thinner resume than Mannion's. It may be a new trend in the NFL, but that doesn't make it less risky.

The Bottom Line

Of the four finalists — Mannion, Jim Bob Cooter, Josh Grizzard, and Jared Johnson — McMullen and Krause both agreed Mannion was the best option. This wasn't the search the Eagles wanted. They originally targeted Mike McDaniel and Brian Daboll, both of whom went elsewhere. But faced with the remaining choices, the Eagles swung for the fences rather than settling for a safe single.

As as framed on the show: "They're not trying to choke up on the bat. They're swinging for the fences." Whether that swing connects or whiffs will define the Eagles' 2026 season — and likely determine whether Nick Sirianni remains the head coach.

Listen & Watch

Catch the full breakdown on Birds 365, available on YouTube and all major podcast platforms.