The Myles Garrett Effect: Cleveland's 4th-Ranked Defense Won Only 5 Games
Cleveland had a better defense than the Eagles last year — and won 5 games. That tells you everything about Myles Garrett's individual impact on a football team.
The Myles Garrett Effect: Cleveland's 4th-Ranked Defense Won Only 5 Games
Here's a stat that should stop every Eagles fan in their tracks: the Cleveland Browns had the fourth-ranked defense in the NFL last season. They won five games.
Five.
The Numbers Don't Lie
Fourth in total defense. Third in pass defense. Seventh on third down. Twelfth in scoring defense — better than the 49ers, the Ravens, the Steelers, and the Bears. All playoff teams. Cleveland's defense outperformed every single one of them statistically.
And the Eagles? Twenty-third on third down. The Eagles, who won 10 games and made the playoffs, had a worse third-down defense than a team that went 5-12.
The difference? Cleveland's offense was historically bad. Their defense, anchored by Myles Garrett, was elite. One player doesn't make a defense — but one player can be the difference between good and dominant.
What Garrett Does to an Already Good Defense
Now imagine transplanting Garrett onto the Eagles' defense. Not replacing anyone — adding to what's already there. Jalen Carter drawing double teams on the interior. Jordan Davis eating blocks. Jalex Hunt on the opposite edge. Nakobe Dean and Zack Baun at linebacker. Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean in the secondary.
That's not just a good defense. That's a defense that could carry an offense through its growing pains under a new coordinator.
The Certainty Factor
Here's the argument that ends all draft debates: there is no player available in the next three NFL Drafts who will provide the production Myles Garrett gives you. None. Zero. The draft is potential and uncertainty. Garrett is a certainty — 51 sacks, 72 tackles for loss, and 100 quarterback hits in his last three seasons alone.
David Bailey from Texas Tech might become a great edge rusher. He might also bust. Nobody knows. Everyone knows what Myles Garrett is.
The Reggie White Parallel
When Reggie White left the Eagles for Green Bay in 1993, he was 31 years old. He played until he was 37. He delivered a Super Bowl for the Packers. Garrett turns 30 in December. The timeline fits. The talent fits. The opportunity is staring the Eagles in the face.
The only question is whether Howie Roseman has the courage to pick up the phone.
Enjoying this article?
JAKIB members get premium articles, ad-free shows, exclusive content, and community access. Starting at $4.99/mo.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Howie Roseman's AJ Brown Answer Tells You Everything You Need to Know
Howie Roseman's AJ Brown Answer Tells You Everything You Need to Know
Howie Roseman addressed the AJ Brown situation at the NFL owners meetings, and his carefully worded response speaks volumes. When a GM says 'he's a member of the team,' history suggests the opposite is coming.
Grading Every Howie Roseman First-Round Pick — And What It Tells Us About Pick 23
Grading Every Howie Roseman First-Round Pick — And What It Tells Us About Pick 23
With the 2026 NFL Draft approaching, we grade every first-round pick of the Howie Roseman era — from Brandon Graham to Nolan Smith — and identify the pattern that should guide the Eagles at pick 23.
The AJ Brown Domino Effect: How One Trade Reshapes the Eagles' Entire Draft Strategy
The AJ Brown Domino Effect: How One Trade Reshapes the Eagles' Entire Draft Strategy
The Eagles appear headed toward trading AJ Brown after June 1, and the ripple effects will transform their approach at pick 23 and beyond. Here's the full breakdown of how one move changes everything.
How the Eagles Could Land Myles Garrett for Just One Net First-Round Pick
How the Eagles Could Land Myles Garrett for Just One Net First-Round Pick
The math works. Trade AJ Brown post-June 1 for a first, trade out of 23 for another, and suddenly three firsts for Myles Garrett only costs the Eagles one net pick. Here's the full blueprint.
The Edge Rusher the Eagles Should Be Targeting Isn't Who You Think
The Edge Rusher the Eagles Should Be Targeting Isn't Who You Think
Forget the big names. NFL Draft analyst Ian Cummings says Akeem Mezador is the best schematic fit for the Eagles' defense — and he could be available at 23.
The Myles Garrett Contract Restructure Explained — And Why the Eagles Can't Wait
The Myles Garrett Contract Restructure Explained — And Why the Eagles Can't Wait
Cleveland pushed Myles Garrett's option bonuses to September, giving them trade flexibility. Here's what it means for the Eagles' edge rusher pursuit and why Howie Roseman can't afford to sit on his hands.
Latest from JAKIB Sports
View all articles →Would You Trade Jalen Hurts for CJ Stroud? Here's the Case
April 7, 2026
Eagles' Edge Rusher Problem Is Bigger Than the Draft Can Fix
April 7, 2026
The AJ Brown Trade Is Coming. The Only Question Is When.
April 7, 2026
Eagles' Safest Draft Pick Has a Name Nobody Can Pronounce
April 7, 2026