The Dual-Threat Blind Spot: Why Mannion's Coaching Tree Raises Major Questions for Jalen Hurts

A Coaching Tree Built for Pocket Passers

When the Philadelphia Eagles officially named Sean Mannion their new offensive coordinator on Thursday, the immediate reaction from Dan Sileo on The National Football Show was pointed and specific: look at who Mannion learned from — and who they coached.

During his NFL playing career, Mannion spent time with the Los Angeles Rams and Minnesota Vikings, sitting in quarterback rooms overseen by some of the game's brightest offensive minds: Sean McVay, Kevin O'Connell, Kevin Stefanski, and Clint Kubiak. Impressive names. But as Sileo was quick to note, there's a glaring common thread.

"Not one of those coaches has ever in any time ever coached a dual-threat quarterback. Not one."

The McVay School: Brilliant, But One-Dimensional

Sean McVay built his offensive empire around Jared Goff and Matthew Stafford — classic pocket quarterbacks who operate from under center or shotgun with minimal designed rushing. Kevin O'Connell, McVay's protégé in Minnesota, runs a similar system with Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold. Stefanski in Cleveland built around Baker Mayfield, then Deshaun Watson. Kubiak's zone-blocking schemes have historically featured traditional drop-back passers.

None of these coaches have ever designed an offense around a quarterback who can beat you with his legs as much as his arm — the way Jalen Hurts can. This isn't a minor quibble. It's the central question of whether Mannion can tailor an offense to the Eagles' most unique weapon.

The Shane Steichen Standard

Sileo's concern becomes clearer when you consider the one Eagles coordinator who actually maximized Hurts. Shane Steichen — who had experience coaching dual-threat quarterbacks including Justin Herbert's more mobile early years — unlocked Hurts' RPO game and designed a system that led to a Super Bowl appearance in the 2022 season.

Every coordinator since Steichen has struggled to replicate that success. Brian Johnson had one year. Kevin Patullo had one disastrous year. Now Mannion arrives with a background rooted entirely in pocket-passer philosophy.

"When Shanahan tried to coach a dual-threat quarterback, he failed. What don't you get?"

What Mannion Must Prove

To be fair, Mannion's most recent role as Green Bay's quarterback coach working with Jordan Love — a mobile passer, though not a true dual threat — suggests some adaptability. Co-host Xander Kraus offered that perspective during the show, noting that Love had a quietly strong 2025 season.

But the question remains: can Mannion design and execute an RPO-heavy, run-first offense that plays to Hurts' dual-threat strengths? Or will the Eagles drift further toward the drop-back passing system that has produced three consecutive years of underperforming passing attacks?

As Sileo put it: the coaching tree is impressive, but the branches don't extend to the type of quarterback waiting for Mannion in Philadelphia.

The National Football Show with Dan Sileo airs daily. Thursday's full episode covered the Mannion hire, Jeff Stoutland's demotion, and the Belichick Hall of Fame controversy.