Jordan Davis or Jalen Carter: The Eagles Can't Pay Both — And That Changes Everything

Jalen Carter enters Year 4 and is now extension-eligible. The projected price tag? A four-year deal worth between $120 and $140 million, averaging more than $30 million per year. Jordan Davis, meanwhile, is looking at a three-year, $55 million deal. Add Jaelan Phillips' expected contract into the mix, and you're staring at over $75 million annually committed to defensive linemen — not one of whom is an elite pass rusher.

That math doesn't work. Not if you want to win a Super Bowl.

The Carter Case

Carter is one of the most disruptive interior defenders in the NFL. He turns 25 in April. He's got the ceiling of a generational player. But here's the catch — when he didn't have quality help beside him early last season, the double teams ate him alive. His production cratered. His effort waned. He might have even gotten hurt from the sheer volume of reps he was absorbing.

When Phillips arrived and gave the defense a legitimate edge presence, Carter transformed. The whole defense got better. That's not a coincidence — it's a blueprint. Before you hand Carter $35 million a year, you better make damn sure you've got someone quality lined up next to him. Pay the man that money and then stick a stiff beside him, and he's back to taking a thousand reps and fighting double teams. How does that make sense?

The Davis Dilemma

Jordan Davis has been a polarizing figure since draft day. The defensive tackle market has exploded — Chris Jones leads at $31.75 million, Milton Williams signed for $26 million, Zach Allen in Denver at $25.5 million. Davis' camp is going to push for top-of-market money.

The question is whether Davis is worth it. He's a space-eater who frees up Carter. He's not a sack artist. He's not a game-wrecker on his own. But his presence makes everyone around him better. That's valuable — the question is how valuable compared to what the Eagles need to spend elsewhere.

The Bradley Chubb Alternative

Here's a smarter play: sign Bradley Chubb to a two-year, $12 million deal. That's $10 million less than what Phillips would cost. Chubb had 8.5 sacks last year. He's played for Vic Fangio in two different places — Denver and Miami — so the defensive coordinator already knows exactly what he's getting. Put Chubb next to Carter, and Carter becomes a better player immediately.

Then take the savings and re-sign Nakobe Dean. Keep the linebacker corps intact. Dean is looking at maybe $12-15 million on the open market — that's the cost of doing business if you want to compete. You want to be in the game or on the sideline?

The Milton Williams Story

There's a fun parallel in Eagles history here. Remember the 2021 draft? Tom Donahue wanted Aleem McNeill. Howie Roseman wanted Milton Williams. Both went in the third round. Both turned out to be excellent players. But Roseman was arguably more right — he got comparable production without paying first-round money. That's Howie ball at its best.

Williams has become a flat-out awesome player — unassuming out of Louisiana Tech with marginal college stats, now earning $26 million a year. The Eagles need that same value-finding instinct right now. Because paying top dollar for Davis, Carter, and an edge rusher simultaneously isn't roster management — it's salary cap suicide.

Carter is the priority. Lock him up. But do it with a plan — get Chubb or a quality edge rusher beside him first, so you're not paying $35 million for a guy who's absorbing double teams because he has no help. That's how championship rosters are built. Not by paying everyone, but by paying the right ones and finding value everywhere else.

YouTube videoWatch on YouTube ↗