Jordan Davis vs. Jalen Carter: The $100 Million Question the Eagles Can't Avoid
The Eagles can't pay both defensive tackles top-dollar. Davis' breakout year just made this the most consequential decision of the offseason.
Jordan Davis vs. Jalen Carter: The $100 Million Question the Eagles Can't Avoid
The Eagles have a $100 million question sitting in the middle of their defensive line, and it's not about whether Jalen Carter is talented. It's about whether they can afford to pay both him and Jordan Davis — and which one actually earned it.
Jordan Davis' Breakout Year
Jordan Davis showed up in 2025. Finally. After three years of questions about his conditioning, his snap count, and whether the 13th overall pick was living up to his draft pedigree, Davis put together the kind of season that changes contract negotiations.
The numbers: 50 solo tackles (second among all defensive interior players per PFF), 5 sacks, 20 assists. For a nose tackle who was supposedly just a run-stuffer, those are elite numbers. Osa Odighizuwa in Dallas is making $20 million a year with fewer tackles and fewer sacks. The market is the market.
The problem? Davis is on his fifth-year option. After this season, he hits unrestricted free agency. The Eagles can't kick this can much further down the road.
The Jalen Carter Question
Carter's projected contract is staggering: four years, $120-140 million, averaging north of $30 million annually. He earned second-team All-Pro honors, which triggers a higher fifth-year option number — likely around $27 million for 2027.
But here's the uncomfortable truth: Carter's talent is undeniable, but his consistency isn't. He disappeared for stretches in 2025 before Jaelan Phillips arrived and took pressure off him. When Carter was the only threat on that interior, opposing offenses schemed around him with double teams and the production cratered.
Compare the market. Chris Jones leads all DTs at $31.75 million per year. Milton Williams just signed for $26 million. The Eagles would be paying Carter top-of-market money for a player who hasn't proven he can carry a defensive line alone.
The Math That Doesn't Work
Pay both? That's roughly $55-60 million per year committed to two defensive tackles. Name another team in the NFL doing that. You can't, because it doesn't exist.
If Davis commands $17-20 million annually — and comparable contracts for Travis Jones (3 years, $40 million) and Vita Vea (4 years, $71 million) suggest he will — and Carter wants $35 million, the Eagles are looking at defensive tackle money that could fund an entire secondary.
The Smart Play
Lock up Davis now. Three years, $55 million feels right — roughly $18 million per year with significant guarantees. Davis proved in 2025 that he's not just a two-down player. His conditioning transformation under DL coach Clint Hurtt was the most underrated storyline of the season.
As for Carter, pick up the fifth-year option and let 2026 determine his long-term value. If he dominates without needing someone else to draw attention, pay him. If he disappears again when he's the focal point, you have your answer.
The irony is rich: the guy drafted 13th overall who everyone questioned is now the safer investment, while the guy everyone called a generational talent is the riskier bet. That's the NFL. Talent without consistency is just potential, and potential doesn't win in January.
Enjoying this article?
JAKIB members get premium articles, ad-free shows, exclusive content, and community access. Starting at $4.99/mo.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Would You Trade Jalen Hurts for CJ Stroud? Here's the Case
Would You Trade Jalen Hurts for CJ Stroud? Here's the Case
A hypothetical that sounds absurd on its surface has become a legitimate Eagles debate: what if Philadelphia could swap Jalen Hurts straight up for CJ Stroud? The answer depends on how you evaluate two very different quarterbacks.
Lavonte David Exposed the Truth About Jalen Hurts — And the Eagles Know It
Lavonte David Exposed the Truth About Jalen Hurts — And the Eagles Know It
Lavonte David — retiring Buccaneers linebacker and future Hall of Famer — went on record: when Tampa played Philadelphia, the entire game plan was to make Jalen Hurts beat them in the passing game. The Eagles couldn't do it.
Sean Mannion Was Hired to Fix the Run Game, Not the Passing Game
Sean Mannion Was Hired to Fix the Run Game, Not the Passing Game
Everyone thinks Sean Mannion is here to fix Jalen Hurts' passing. The real reason is simpler: Saquon Barkley got hit behind the line on 40% of his carries, and the run game collapsed.
Jalen Carter's Shoulder Issues Could Derail His Massive Extension
Jalen Carter's Shoulder Issues Could Derail His Massive Extension
Jalen Carter ranked 115th of 130 in run defense last season because he couldn't lift weights due to chronic shoulder pain. Now his contract extension talks just got a lot more complicated.
If the Hurts-Eagles Divorce Happens, It Will Be Uglier Than Carson Wentz
If the Hurts-Eagles Divorce Happens, It Will Be Uglier Than Carson Wentz
The potential Jalen Hurts trade has two factors that didn't exist with Carson Wentz: a no-trade clause and Nicole Lynn running Clutch Sports. If this marriage ends, it's going to be messy.
Where Does Jalen Hurts Actually Rank Among NFL Quarterbacks?
Where Does Jalen Hurts Actually Rank Among NFL Quarterbacks?
Ranking Jalen Hurts against all 32 starting NFL quarterbacks produces a result that will upset both his biggest supporters and his harshest critics. The truth is somewhere nobody wants to look.