Jalen Hurts vs Nick Sirianni: Who Deserves More Credit for Eagles Success?

The Dynasty Question Comes to Philadelphia

When evaluating the New England Patriots' dynasty, the eternal debate centers on Bill Belichick versus Tom Brady. Who deserved more credit for two decades of unprecedented success? Now Philadelphia faces its own version of that question with Nick Sirianni and Jalen Hurts.

The discussion on The National Football Show tackled this fascinating debate about the Eagles' recent success and where the primary credit should land.

The Case for Jalen Hurts

Jalen Hurts' versatility and decision-making have been central to the Eagles' success during the Sirianni era. Consider the quarterback's willingness to step aside and let the run game dominate during the 2022 season.

How many quarterbacks with Hurts' talent and ego would have embraced a secondary role when Saquon Barkley and the rushing attack took center stage? Most franchise quarterbacks would demand more touches, more opportunities to showcase their abilities.

Instead, Hurts recognized what gave the team the best chance to win and embraced it completely. When the Super Bowl spotlight arrived, he delivered in the passing game while maintaining his effectiveness as a rusher.

The Scrambling Factor

Hurts' ability to create plays outside the pocket has been crucial to offensive success. Throughout the 2022 season especially, broken plays became explosive gains thanks to Hurts' mobility and arm strength.

Defenses consistently struggled to contain Hurts when initial concepts broke down. His scrambling ability bought time for receivers to get open while creating rushing lanes that defenses couldn't account for.

These improvised moments often provided the difference between three-and-outs and sustained drives. That type of quarterback impact can't be easily replicated through scheme or coaching.

The Consistency Across Personnel

Look at the running backs who have thrived in the Eagles offense during Hurts' tenure: Miles Sanders, D'Andre Swift, and Saquon Barkley all found success in different seasons with largely the same supporting cast.

The common denominator isn't just the offensive line or coaching scheme—it's Hurts' ability to make defenses account for an extra gap defender. His rushing threat opens up opportunities for every skill position player.

Receiving weapons like A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith have consistently produced 1,000-yard seasons, often in 16 games rather than the full 17-game schedule. That level of production across multiple players suggests quarterback play elevating everyone around him.

The Case for Nick Sirianni

Sirianni's win-loss record speaks for itself. The head coach has consistently put the Eagles in position to succeed, regardless of the specific challenges each season presented.

Delegation has been one of Sirianni's strongest attributes. He's put quality coordinators in position to succeed, from Shane Steichen's offensive creativity to Vic Fangio's defensive expertise. Good leaders know how to empower their staff.

Sirianni has also shown adaptability throughout his tenure. When the offense struggled with Kevin Patullo's concepts, adjustments were made. When defensive changes were needed, personnel moves followed.

The Coordinator Carousel Success

Multiple coordinators have found success within Sirianni's framework. Steichen parlayed his Eagles success into a head coaching opportunity, while Fangio has restored the defense's credibility.

This suggests Sirianni creates an environment where good coaches can thrive rather than micromanaging every decision. That's a valuable leadership trait that directly contributes to team success.

The Coaching Comparison

The recent playoffs highlighted just how much coaching matters across the NFL. Teams with superior talent lost to better-coached squads with less individual ability.

When Kyle Shanahan took a depleted 49ers roster into Philadelphia and executed a superior game plan, it exposed some of Sirianni's limitations. The failure to have better answers for fourth-and-11 situations or adjust to obvious defensive tendencies raises questions about in-game management.

The Answer Deficit

Sirianni's biggest weakness appears to be providing solutions when things go wrong. He delegates well when everything runs smoothly, but struggles to course-correct during adversity.

That's a significant concern for a head coach, especially one working with championship-level talent. The best coaches find ways to maximize their roster's potential even when initial plans fail.

The Verdict

Jalen Hurts deserves primary credit for the Eagles' success during the Sirianni era. His versatility, leadership, and willingness to sacrifice personal statistics for team success have been the driving forces behind consistent winning.

Hurts' ability to elevate everyone around him—from running backs to receivers to the offensive line—represents true franchise quarterback impact. His mobility and decision-making have masked coaching deficiencies while maximizing talent across the roster.

Sirianni deserves credit for creating a positive environment and hiring quality assistants, but the quarterback's unique skill set has been the foundation of everything else.

As discussed on The National Football Show, coaching matters tremendously in today's NFL. However, elite quarterback play that raises everyone's ceiling matters even more.

For more Eagles analysis and debates, check out JAKIB Sports membership for exclusive content throughout the offseason.

Stay Connected

Catch the full episode of The National Football Show and never miss a take. Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple Podcasts | Spotify.

For exclusive Eagles coverage and analysis, check out JAKIB Sports membership.