Stop Trying to Change Jalen Hurts

The 2022 Blueprint Is Right There

Jalen Hurts was the runner-up for NFL MVP in 2022. The Eagles were a top-five offense in every major category — rushing, passing, scoring. They went to the Super Bowl. Hurts was the engine that made it all work.

That was three seasons ago. Since then, the Eagles have spent two years tweaking, adjusting, and trying to evolve Hurts into a different kind of quarterback. The results? A declining statistical trajectory, a Super Bowl win that was built on Saquon Barkley's legs more than Hurts' arm, and a 2025 season where the offense regressed under Kevin Patullo.

At some point, someone needs to ask the obvious question: why are the Eagles trying to change a unique, successful quarterback?

The Larry Caris Lesson

Nick Sirianni tells a lot of stories. Most of them make your eyes roll. But his best story — the one that should be tattooed on the wall of the Eagles' offensive meeting room — is about his interview with former Colts coach Larry Caris.

Caris asked Sirianni what kind of offense he wanted to run. Sirianni started giving the textbook answer about his scheme philosophy. Caris slammed the table and said: "You don't even know who your players are yet."

Build the offense around the players you have. Not the players you wish you had. Not the scheme you saw work somewhere else. The actual human beings on your roster.

YouTube videoWatch on YouTube ↗

The Plus-One Is Everything

Jalen Hurts' greatest strength is the plus-one in the running game. When the defense has to account for Hurts as a runner, everything opens up. Play-action works better because the linebackers can't cheat. The passing lanes widen because safeties have to respect the read option. Saquon Barkley gets one-on-one blocking because the defense can't commit an extra body to the box.

The 49ers aren't asking Brock Purdy to run the read option. Why are the Eagles asking Jalen Hurts to be a traditional play-action dropback passer?

The talk coming out of the owners meetings is all about play-action passing, under-center looks, and the Minnesota game as a template. That's fine as a spring project. It's fine to expand the toolkit. But when September arrives, the offense needs to be built around what Hurts does at an elite level — not what the coaching staff hopes he can develop into.

Saquon's Role in the Equation

Saquon Barkley's historic 2024 season changed the Eagles' offensive identity. When you have a running back gaining 2,000+ yards, you lean into it. Hurts became a game manager, and it worked — all the way to a championship.

But last season showed the limits of that approach. The offensive line struggled. Saquon got hit behind the line of scrimmage at an alarming rate. Hurts defaulted to escaping the pocket and hero ball when the run game stalled.

The realistic projection for Saquon in 2026 is around 1,300 yards behind a healthy offensive line. That's still elite production. But it's not 2,000 yards. The Eagles can't just push the Saquon button and coast to the playoffs.

Hurts needs to be the best player on this team again. Not MVP caliber necessarily — but the guy who makes everyone around him better because defenses can't solve the dual-threat puzzle.

The Real Test for Sean Mannion

This is where Sean Mannion earns his paycheck or loses his job. The temptation will be to install the Shanahan-McVay system he grew up in — wide zone, boot action, traditional quarterback play. That system has produced elite offenses across the league.

But it's never been run by Jalen Hurts. And Hurts isn't Sam Darnold or Matthew Stafford or Jared Goff.

The best version of Sean Mannion's offense incorporates elements of the Shanahan tree while centering the quarterback who's been to two Super Bowls. Take what Hurts does well and scheme around it. Add play-action as a complement, not a foundation.

If Mannion tries to change Hurts into something he's not, we'll be having this same conversation next March with a new offensive coordinator's name attached. Build around the quarterback you have. It's not complicated.