Is Jalen Hurts Actually Part of the Eagles' Future?

The Uncomfortable Question

Jalen Hurts sits at the center of Philadelphia's most difficult roster evaluation. Despite being the starting quarterback with a massive contract, legitimate questions exist about whether he represents a long-term solution or an expensive placeholder.

The discussion on The National Football Show highlighted a stark reality: many Eagles fans no longer view their quarterback as untouchable when discussing the team's future core.

The Two-Year Window

Hurts has two years remaining on his current deal, but NFL contracts for underperforming quarterbacks rarely run their full course. If Philadelphia doesn't see significant improvement, they'll face a decision point sooner rather than later.

Two years isn't really "future" planning in NFL terms - it's more like short-term management. True franchise quarterbacks get discussed in terms of five to ten-year windows, not two-year spans.

Performance Plateau

The most concerning aspect of Hurts' situation isn't just current performance, but the lack of clear upward trajectory. Quarterbacks typically show their ceiling by year four or five, and Hurts appears to have plateaued rather than continued developing.

This stagnation becomes particularly problematic when considering the investment Philadelphia has made in supporting cast and coaching. If elite weapons and scheming can't unlock higher-level play, what will?

The Hot Seat Reality

Quarterbacks on "hot seats" aren't typically considered core players for future building. The pressure surrounding Hurts suggests the organization has already begun evaluating alternatives, even if not publicly.

When fans and media openly debate a quarterback's future, it usually signals that internal discussions are already happening. Front offices rarely get surprised by quarterback situations.

Comparison to Other Core Players

Unlike other Eagles players who project as building blocks, Hurts faces questions about fundamental skills and ceiling. Core players typically show clear paths to improvement or at least sustained excellence.

The contrast is stark when comparing Hurts to someone like Jalen Carter, whose talent and age make him obviously untouchable, or DeVonta Smith, whose consistency and skill set translate across any system.

The Contract Complication

Hurts' contract makes any potential move complicated but not impossible. Teams regularly eat dead money to move on from quarterbacks who don't fit their vision. The salary cap hit would hurt, but keeping an ineffective quarterback hurts more.

Philadelphia has shown willingness to make difficult financial decisions when necessary. If they determine Hurts isn't the answer, they'll find a way to move forward.

System Dependence

Perhaps most troubling is how system-dependent Hurts appears to be. Elite quarterbacks elevate their supporting cast and succeed across different schemes. Hurts seems to need specific conditions to succeed, which limits his value and the team's flexibility.

JAKIB Sports membership provides detailed analysis of how teams evaluate quarterback situations and plan for transitions.

The Draft Factor

The 2025 draft class doesn't offer obvious quarterback solutions, but that could change quickly. Teams often identify prospects who weren't initially considered first-round talents. If Philadelphia sees someone they believe in, Hurts' timeline could accelerate.

Alternatively, the Eagles might need to explore trade possibilities or wait for the right draft class to emerge.

Organizational Patience

How much patience does Philadelphia have for continued struggles? The organization has invested heavily in building around Hurts, but those investments lose value if the centerpiece can't deliver.

Franchises succeed by knowing when to persist and when to pivot. The Eagles face that decision with their quarterback position.

The Broader Context

This quarterback uncertainty affects every other roster decision. Building around Hurts requires different personnel and scheme choices than preparing for his replacement.

The Eagles can't fully commit to their future direction without resolving the quarterback situation one way or another.

What Success Looks Like

For Hurts to remain part of Philadelphia's core, he needs to show dramatic improvement in 2025. Marginal gains won't be sufficient given the investment and expectations.

The bar has been set high, and anything short of playoff success might seal his fate as a transitional player rather than a franchise cornerstone.

The Verdict

Based on current trajectory and organizational patience, Hurts appears more likely to be replaced than extended beyond his current deal. That reality makes him a short-term consideration rather than a long-term building block.

The Eagles' future success may depend more on their willingness to move on from Hurts than their ability to fix him.

Stay Connected

Catch the full episode of The National Football Show and never miss a take. Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple Podcasts | Spotify.

For exclusive Eagles coverage and analysis, check out JAKIB Sports membership.