The Ben Simmons Comparison for Jalen Hurts Is Uncomfortable — and Accurate
Radio host Mike Gill drew a direct line between Jalen Hurts and Ben Simmons — two supremely talented Philadelphia athletes who reached elite status but refused to add the one skill that would take them higher. The comparison stings because it fits.
The JAKIB Staff
contributor
The Comparison Nobody Wanted to Hear
Mike Gill didn't mince words on Birds 365 Tuesday morning. After reading ESPN's explosive report on Jalen Hurts and the Eagles' offensive dysfunction, the 97.3 ESPN radio host went straight to the most uncomfortable comparison available in Philadelphia sports: Ben Simmons.
"It's like Ben Simmons. I don't need to shoot. I'm still an All-Star," Gill said. "And people say, yeah, but you could be an elite player if you incorporated this. Well, I don't need to."
The parallel is striking. Simmons had generational talent as a playmaker and defender, reached three All-Star games, but stubbornly refused to develop a jump shot. Hurts won a Super Bowl playing a specific brand of football, and according to the ESPN report, has consistently resisted expanding beyond it.
Where the Comparison Gets Uncomfortable
Gill pushed the analogy further: "This is almost what you're hearing here — I won a Super Bowl doing this. I don't need to do that. And it's like, do you want to win one Super Bowl? Do you want to just be the guy that won one?"
The ESPN report detailed how Hurts fought Kellen Moore on motion concepts in 2024, continually resists going under center because he doesn't like turning his back to the defense, and suggested the four verticals play that ended the Eagles' season against San Francisco.
A source close to Hurts acknowledged he had "too many yes people around him" — language that echoes the enabling environment around Simmons in his final seasons with the Sixers.
The Critical Difference
There is one major difference that makes Hurts' situation more fixable: Simmons' shooting deficiency was a skill limitation. Hurts' resistance appears to be a preference. He has shown the ability to make plays under center and execute play-action — he just doesn't want to do it consistently.
That distinction matters. Sean Mannion's McVay-Shanahan system demands exactly what Hurts has resisted. If the ESPN report is accurate about the degree of pushback, the 2026 season becomes the ultimate test of whether Hurts can evolve past his comfort zone.
Simmons never did. Philadelphia is hoping Hurts is different.
Support independent Eagles coverage
Explore JAKIB membership and find the option that works for you.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Caleb Williams’ Improvement Starts With the Structure Around Him
Caleb Williams completed 70.9 percent of his passes across five starts through Week 8. Protection, run-game connections and continuity offer a framework for examining the improvement without taking credit away from the quarterback or treating a small sample as causal proof.
Saquon Barkley’s Value in an Eagles Rebuild Goes Beyond His Stat Line
Saquon Barkley’s leadership belongs in the Eagles’ roster discussion alongside his football role and the opportunities available to younger backs. His contract already runs through 2028, and long-term value does not settle game-day medical questions.
Joe Milton's First Eagles Test Includes What Happens Before the Snap
The Eagles must decide what Joe Milton can read from a stationary formation, what motion adds and whether gathering that clue leaves the rest of the offense enough time to execute.
Notre Dame’s Miami Test Puts CJ Carr at the Center of the Playoff Argument
CJ Carr can keep Notre Dame’s offense flexible if Miami crowds the running game. The Irish have a direct opportunity to strengthen their playoff case, with two very different paths through the matchup.
The DeVonta Smith Trade Question Starts With the Eagles’ Next Quarterback
Keeping DeVonta Smith should be the starting position. The case for a trade depends on the next quarterback, the rebuilding timeline and an actual return.
The Eagles Need an Evaluation Plan for Their Young Players
The Eagles should give young players defined jobs and meaningful opportunities to show progress. Availability, clear teaching and comparable assignments matter more than an empty snap total.