Are the Eagles STILL a Top 5 Team? A Brutally Honest Power Ranking

Three months ago, the Eagles were playing for a championship. Now they're installing a new offensive system with a coordinator who has never called a play at any level of football, their best receiver might get traded, and 21 players could walk in free agency. So where does Philadelphia actually stand?

The honest answer: still in the top tier, but hanging on by thinner threads than Eagles fans want to admit.

The Case for Top 5

The talent is still there. Jalen Hurts is a franchise quarterback signed through 2028. Saquon Barkley is coming off a historic rushing season. The defensive line remains one of the best in football. Nick Sirianni, whatever you think of his playoff performance, has a winning record and the locker room's respect.

The NFC isn't exactly loaded with juggernauts, either. The Lions, 49ers, and Packers are the clear top three. After that, there's a significant drop-off where the Eagles, Cowboys, and Commanders are jostling for position. In that tier, Philly's roster depth gives them the edge.

The Case Against

Sean Mannion has never called plays. Not in the NFL, not in college, not in high school. The Eagles are betting that a lifetime of football knowledge and Kyle Shanahan's coaching tree principles will translate to game-day execution. That's an enormous gamble with a Super Bowl window that's open right now.

If Brown gets traded, the offense loses its most dynamic weapon. If Lane Johnson can't return from his Lisfranc injury at age 36, the offensive line takes a significant hit. If Jaelan Phillips walks in free agency, the pass rush thins out. Any one of these outcomes is manageable. All three together could drop the Eagles from contender to pretender overnight.

The Howie Factor

Here's what keeps the Eagles in the conversation: Howie Roseman doesn't sit still. The man who turned draft picks into A.J. Brown, traded for Saquon Barkley's services, and built a roster deep enough to absorb injuries all season isn't going to watch the offseason happen to him. Whether it's a splashy free agent signing, a draft-day trade, or a move nobody sees coming, Roseman will be aggressive.

The question is whether aggressive moves can compensate for the uncertainty at offensive coordinator. Great players and great schemes are both necessary. Right now, the Eagles have the players but are betting on an unproven scheme.

The Verdict

Top 5? Yes — barely. But the margin for error is razor-thin, and the next six weeks of free agency and draft prep will determine whether the Eagles enter 2026 as legitimate Super Bowl favorites or a talented team with too many question marks. The ceiling is a championship. The floor is 9-8 and a wild card exit. Howie's offseason will decide which one we get.