Skip to main content

Eagles Have a Safety Problem Nobody's Talking About

The Eagles literally don't have a starting safety right now. Sydney Brown is more likely to be traded than start. This is the biggest hole on the roster.

T

The JAKIB Staff

contributor

3 min read

The Biggest Hole Nobody's Discussing

While the fanbase debates AJ Brown's future and the new offense, there's a quiet crisis brewing on defense. The Eagles don't have a starting safety. Not a questionable one. Not an underwhelming one. They literally don't have one.

If the season started today, the Eagles would be trotting out... who, exactly? Sydney Brown? The evidence suggests he's more likely to be traded than to start. Michael Carter at safety full-time? That's not a plan that should generate confidence in anyone.

The Blankenship Aftermath

Losing Reed Blankenship wasn't supposed to create this kind of void. He was a solid starter — great instincts, tough tackler, respected by Vic Fangio — but he had clear limitations in coverage. The modern NFL demands range from the safety position, and Blankenship couldn't always provide it.

But here's the thing: at least he was a starter. At least he could be trusted to handle the communication responsibilities that Fangio's defense demands. Now that he's gone, there's nobody on the roster who can step into that role without significant growing pains.

Drew Maccubu showed promise as a rookie last season, but he's still developing. He had coverage busts. He had communication breakdowns. Putting another young, unproven safety next to him is asking for trouble.

The Options Are Limited

The free agent market offers one realistic name: Marcus Epps. He knows the system from his previous stint in Philadelphia, and he could serve as a stopgap while a young player develops. But Epps isn't the same player he was in 2022. He's a bridge, not a solution.

In the draft, Jalen Kilgore from South Carolina is coming in for a 30 visit. Asakee Wheatley from Penn State is another name to watch in the late day-two, early day-three range. But drafting a safety to start immediately next to Maccubu is risky.

The Real Fix

The Eagles need a two-pronged approach: sign a veteran who can start from Week 1, then draft a safety who can develop behind him. Epps plus a day-two pick is the most logical path.

But with $38 million in cap space and needs at edge rusher, offensive tackle, and wide receiver, the Eagles are going to have to prioritize. And right now, safety isn't getting the attention it deserves.

That needs to change. Because a defense built around Jalen Carter, Quinyon Mitchell, and Cooper DeJean can't afford to have a liability at the back end. The front seven creates chaos. The corners lock down. But if nobody's covering the deep middle? It all falls apart.

Support independent Eagles coverage

Explore JAKIB membership and find the option that works for you.

Explore membership
T

The JAKIB Staff

AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.

Share this article

Related Articles

Analysis

Dexter Lawrence's Bengals Impact Sets a Test for the Eagles' Interior

Cincinnati's November 15 defensive sequence gives the Eagles a concrete interior test: distinguish documented team results from an individual defender's demonstrated contribution.

Analysis

Quinyon Mitchell Gives the Eagles a Standard for Rebuild Cornerstones

Quinyon Mitchell offers a useful standard for Philadelphia's next core: dependable assignments and room to adapt. That standard also leaves space for younger players to prove themselves.

Analysis

Dallas’ Coaching Problem Runs Deeper Than Replacing Brian Schottenheimer

Dallas won despite 14 accepted penalties for 153 yards against Indianapolis. Schottenheimer’s next test is whether reviewing those mistakes helps the Cowboys preserve the next advantage they create.

Analysis

The Eagles’ Backup Quarterback Problem Is Bigger Than One Bad Start

The Eagles invested in backup quarterbacks. The harder question is whether practice work, scheme fit and a usable replacement plan prepared the offense to function when the quarterback changed.

Analysis

Cooper DeJean's Safety Label Does Not Explain His Slot Problems

DeJean's announced safety role applies to base personnel, with slot duties in nickel. Evaluating his coverage requires separating those jobs before assigning a cause to the problems.

Analysis

Notre Dame’s Miami Test Puts CJ Carr at the Center of the Playoff Argument

CJ Carr can keep Notre Dame’s offense flexible if Miami crowds the running game. The Irish have a direct opportunity to strengthen their playoff case, with two very different paths through the matchup.