Eagles Offense Needs to Be Built Around Jalen Hurts, Not Kyle Shanahan's System
The Eagles keep chasing trendy offensive schemes instead of maximizing what Jalen Hurts does best. It's time to stop forcing square pegs and build around the quarterback they have.
The JAKIB Staff
contributor
Stop Copying Shanahan. Start Building Around Hurts.
The Eagles have a quarterback problem, but it's not the quarterback. It's the approach.
For two offseasons now, Philadelphia has flirted with offensive concepts borrowed from Kyle Shanahan's tree — outside zone schemes, pre-snap motion packages, concepts designed for a different type of quarterback. And for two years, the results have been the same: an offense that looks good on paper but feels forced on the field.
The solution isn't complicated. Build around the damn quarterback.
The Square Peg Problem
Jalen Hurts is not a Shanahan quarterback. He's not Jimmy Garoppolo. He's not Kirk Cousins. Trying to run someone else's system through a quarterback with a completely different skill set is like pounding a square peg because sports radio says you should.
Hurts is at his best in RPO concepts, under center play action, and designed quarterback runs. He's elite at extending plays and making throws on the move. The Eagles' most dominant stretch in franchise history — the 2023 Super Bowl run — was built on exactly those concepts.
So why are they trying to reinvent the wheel?
Evolution, Not Revolution
Nobody is saying the offense shouldn't evolve. Every quarterback should expand their game. You work on it in the offseason, you add wrinkles, you try to grow. That's what good teams do.
But when the games start, you build around what your quarterback does best. You don't ask him to do things he's not comfortable with because it fits a schematic trend. The NFL is full of copycat coaches chasing the offense of the moment. The great ones build systems around their players, not the other way around.
Kellen Moore's Challenge
New offensive coordinator Kellen Moore has a choice. He can try to install his vision of what an offense should look like, or he can study what Hurts does at an elite level and design an attack that maximizes those strengths.
The Eagles don't need to reinvent the entire wheel. They need to sharpen the wheel they have. Under center play action with Saquon Barkley in the backfield. RPOs that let Hurts read the defense and make quick decisions. Designed runs on critical downs.
That's not boring. That's winning football.
Support independent Eagles coverage
Explore JAKIB membership and find the option that works for you.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Three-and-Outs Are Turning the Eagles’ Defense Into an Attrition Test
Carolina’s 79 offensive snaps put a concrete number on the burden facing the Eagles’ defense. Sustained offensive possessions and defensive stops on favorable third downs would address different parts of the same workload problem.
The Eagles’ Trade Deadline Math Goes Beyond a Future Comp Pick
A potential compensatory pick gives the Eagles one reason to keep a contributor, but future free-agent decisions can change that calculation. Any trade offer also has to cover the player’s football value and the cost of replacing his work.
The Eagles’ Coaching Verdict Cannot Ignore the Roster
The Eagles’ coaching evaluation has to account for roster limitations without letting them excuse every failure. Protection assignments and the staff’s adjustments offer a more useful test than a blanket verdict.
Tanner McKee’s Dallas Test Starts Over the Middle
Quick middle-field routes offer Tanner McKee a practical test against Dallas. The Eagles need timing, protection and receiving options that make an early throw productive.
A One-Year Bridge Could Separate the Eagles’ Jalen Hurts Decisions
A proposed one-year bridge would let the Eagles separate immediate continuity from a long commitment to Jalen Hurts. Its value would depend on the football evidence and the agreement both sides could reach.
The Eagles’ Line Rebuild Has Two Different Clocks
The Eagles can pursue a faster interior rebuild while treating tackle succession as a separate problem. That distinction changes how they should spend picks and evaluate veterans.