Nolan Smith Is Already a Successful Eagles Draft Pick—Even If He Leaves

Nolan Smith is already a successful Philadelphia Eagles draft pick, even if his next major contract eventually comes from another team. The 30th overall selection in 2023 helped drive a Super Bowl run, earned a fifth-year option and developed into a complete edge defender. A future roster decision cannot erase that value.

The Eagles exercised Smith's option through 2027 after he produced four sacks during the Super Bowl LIX postseason, the most by an Eagle in a single playoff run. That is not theoretical upside. It is premium production at the most important point of a championship season.

The Super Bowl Run Changed the Grade

First-round picks are often judged as if every slot carries the same expectation. It does not. Smith was selected near the end of Round 1, not in the top five, and Philadelphia needed him to grow into a useful starter rather than become an immediate franchise-changing superstar.

He did more than that during the 2024 title run. Smith recorded 6.5 sacks in the regular season and added four in the playoffs. His postseason surge established an Eagles record and helped a dominant defense finish the job.

That contribution alone gives the pick lasting value. Draft success is not limited to signing a player for his entire career. It includes what the team wins while controlling his early seasons, and Smith has already helped Philadelphia win the sport's biggest prize.

YouTube videoWatch on YouTube ↗

Injuries Are the Real Long-Term Question

Smith's evaluation cannot ignore availability. He suffered a torn triceps in the Super Bowl victory and has dealt with shoulder concerns during his career. His size also creates a different projection from the NFL's longest, most powerful edge rushers.

Those factors matter when a team considers a major extension. The Eagles can value Smith as a strong run defender, disciplined edge setter and productive rusher while still deciding that another long-term investment carries more upside or less medical risk.

That would be roster management, not an admission that the pick failed. Philadelphia has already secured Smith through 2027, giving the organization time to evaluate his health, role and price without rushing into a decision.

Greenard and Hunt Change the Contract Equation

Jonathan Greenard's arrival gives the Eagles a proven pass-rush headliner. He recorded 12 sacks in his 2024 Pro Bowl season with Minnesota, and Philadelphia acquired him to finish pressures created by an interior led by Jalen Carter and Jordan Davis.

Jalyx Hunt changes the equation from the other direction. Hunt led the Eagles with 6.5 sacks in 2025 and still carries developmental upside. Smith is currently the more complete edge defender, particularly against the run, but Hunt's growth could persuade Philadelphia to reserve future money for the younger player's ceiling.

The presence of both players does not make Smith disposable. It gives Vic Fangio a deeper rotation and protects the defense if Greenard needs time or Hunt's development is uneven. Edge depth is a competitive advantage, especially when each player brings a different strength.

A Second Contract Elsewhere Would Not Mean Failure

Smith is positioned to earn another NFL contract if he stays healthy and maintains his current level. Whether the Eagles offer it will depend on price, the development of Hunt, Greenard's impact and the other extensions competing for the same salary-cap space.

Philadelphia has lost good players before because a strong roster creates choices. The correct measure is not whether every draft pick remains an Eagle forever. It is whether the player outperformed his cost, helped the team win and created options before reaching the open market.

Smith has already cleared that standard. The next two seasons can raise his value further, but they do not need to rescue his reputation. Four postseason sacks and a championship contribution made him a successful pick. If another team eventually pays for what the Eagles developed, both things can be true: Philadelphia drafted well, and the roster became too deep to keep everyone.