NFC East Reality Check: Cowboys Rising, Commanders Falling, Giants Still a Mystery

The Cowboys Are Two Players Away

Nobody in Philadelphia wants to hear this, but the Dallas Cowboys might be closer to contention than anyone realizes.

Dallas had the number-one offense in football last year under Brian Schottenheimer. Dak Prescott looked as sharp as he's looked in three years. CeeDee Lamb is an elite weapon. The offensive line is functional. What they didn't have was a defense — they finished dead last.

But here's the math: if Dallas moves from 32nd to 15th in total defense, they're a playoff team. And with Quinyon Williams already acquired via the Micah Parsons trade, Kenny Clark anchoring the middle, and Christian Parker installing a Vic Fangio-style scheme, that jump isn't unrealistic.

Add Max Crosby from the Raiders — a real possibility according to Adam Schefter, with both the Eagles and Cowboys in pursuit — and suddenly Dallas has a defensive front that can generate pressure. Pair that with Nakobe Dean, who could follow his former position coach to Dallas in free agency, and the Cowboys defense looks completely different.

Don't Sleep on Schottenheimer

When Dallas hired Brian Schottenheimer as head coach, the reaction was predictable: Jerry Jones hired a lackey. A yes-man. Another puppet.

Then Schottenheimer went out and oversaw the best offense in football. Dak Prescott had his best season in years. The play-calling was aggressive, creative, and effective. First-year head coaches don't typically produce the top-ranked offense in the NFL.

The defense stunk, but that wasn't his fault. He's an offensive coach who inherited a defensive disaster. Give him the pieces, and Dallas becomes dangerous.

Christian Parker Changes the Equation

The Eagles lost Christian Parker to Dallas, and Cowboys fans should be excited. Parker spent two years learning under Vic Fangio in Philadelphia — the same system that produced the best defense in football.

Parker's introductory press conference sounded like Mike Tomlin. No fear. Clear vision. He talked about running a multiple front — three-four base, four-three looks, even four-two packages — all catered to the talent on the roster. That's not some rookie coordinator reading from a playbook. That's a coach who learned from the best and is ready to apply it.

The Commanders Are Going Backward

Washington's 2025 was a mirage, and 2026 is where the illusion breaks.

Jayden Daniels is a good quarterback — potentially a great one. But one player can't fix a roster that was constructed with short-term thinking. Terry McLaurin's extension came too late and cost too much. The best players on that defense are 29 or older. They traded Jonathan Allen. The offensive line's biggest acquisition was Laremy Tunsil, who's in his 30s.

The Commanders made every mistake possible in roster construction last offseason, prioritizing the appearance of contention over actually building something sustainable. Daniels will keep them competitive on Sundays, but the supporting cast is eroding faster than they can rebuild it.

The Giants Are the Wild Card

New York built an impressive coaching staff. They've got Malik Nabers, who's a genuine star. The defensive line has talent. On paper, the Giants shouldn't finish fourth in the division.

But Jackson Dart is the question mark that hovers over everything. The rookie quarterback from Ole Miss has the athleticism to make plays when the pocket breaks down — but in the NFL, you have to beat defenses from the pocket consistently. Dart struggled with that in college more than Jalen Hurts ever did.

John Horrball is a legit head coaching candidate who could build something real in New York. But until Dart proves he can function as a consistent passer, the Giants ceiling is capped.

The Eagles Are Still the Team to Beat — For Now

Philadelphia has won back-to-back NFC East titles. They've been to two Super Bowls in three years. The talent is there, the coaching is elite on defense, and the infrastructure is solid.

But the gap is closing. Dallas is investing in defense. The Cowboys' offense is already the best in football. If they fix even half their defensive issues, this becomes a legitimate two-horse race.

The Eagles' edge comes down to two things: Vic Fangio and offensive line play. If either of those falter, the NFC East crown is up for grabs. Philadelphia can't afford complacency. Not this offseason. Not this year.