Too Many Cooks or the Smartest Move the Eagles Made This Offseason?

Three Finalists, One Staff

The Eagles interviewed 17 candidates for their offensive coordinator job. Seven made it to the final round. Three got hired — Sean Mannion as the OC, Josh Grizzard as pass game coordinator, and Jerrod Johnson as senior offensive assistant.

On the surface, it looks like a coaching staff that doesn't know what it wants to be. Three guys who all thought they were interviewing for the top job, now sharing a conference room. Critics are already calling it too many cooks in the kitchen.

They're wrong.

How NFL Coaching Hierarchies Actually Work

Here's what a lot of people don't understand about how NFL coaching staffs function: it's a flow chart, not a committee. The roles are clearly defined. The offensive coordinator runs the offense. The pass game coordinator handles his specific area. The senior offensive assistant does special projects.

Josh Grizzard isn't stepping in to talk to Jalen Hurts on a daily basis. That's Parks Frazier's job as quarterback coach. Jerrod Johnson isn't calling plays on third down. It's collaborative, but the chain of command is real.

The comparison to the Matt Patricia-Sean Desai disaster of 2023 doesn't hold up. Patricia was a former head coach and Super Bowl-winning defensive coordinator. Everyone knew who he was and why he was there — as a safety net for a struggling coordinator. Grizzard and Johnson don't carry that profile or that baggage.

The Real Reason — And Nick Almost Said It

Nick Sirianni came dangerously close to saying the quiet part out loud at the owners meetings. When asked about having so many offensive coaches, he started down the path of "we have guys in position who could take over if..." before catching himself and pivoting to "...if a guy leaves, which has been a problem when we have success."

YouTube videoWatch on YouTube ↗

That's the optimistic framing, and it's the right one. The Eagles have lost offensive coordinators after successful seasons repeatedly. Shane Steichen left. Kellen Moore left. If Mannion is great, he'll leave too. Having Grizzard or Frazier ready to step up internally is a genuine competitive advantage.

But the insurance policy also works the other way. If Mannion struggles — and he's a first-time play-caller, so growing pains are almost guaranteed — the Eagles have coaches on staff who can absorb some of the load without making a mid-season change that torpedoes the locker room.

The Jerrod Johnson Factor

Jerrod Johnson's hiring is the most interesting of the three. He was a rising star in Houston's coaching tree before things fell apart with C.J. Stroud. It was late in the hiring cycle when Houston imploded, and the last thing a young coach wants is a gap year on the resume.

This looks like a favor — similar to Jim Bob Cooter's stint with the Eagles, or Marcus Brady's one-year consultant role. Johnson gets a landing spot. The Eagles get a talented coach in the building. If things go well, he could be next in line. If he gets a better offer elsewhere after one year, no harm done.

Nick's Biggest Challenge

The coaching staff being talented isn't the concern. Managing it is. Nick Sirianni has to establish crystal-clear roles and make sure egos don't become a problem — especially if the offense hits a rough patch in the first month of the season.

He's done this before. He's managed strong personalities on his staff throughout his tenure. But he's never done it with a first-time play-caller surrounded by guys who also wanted the job.

If he pulls it off, this coaching staff could be the reason the Eagles survive a coordinator carousel that's derailed their offense for three straight years. If he doesn't, the too-many-cooks crowd will have their told-you-so moment.

Smart money is on Sirianni making it work. He's gotten much better at the political side of coaching — and this is a political challenge as much as a football one.