Jalen Carter Won't Sign Cheap — And the Market Proves He Shouldn't
With the defensive market exploding and agent Drew Rosenhaus in his corner, Jalen Carter has zero incentive to take a discount from the Eagles.
Jalen Carter Won't Sign Cheap — And the Market Proves He Shouldn't
Jalen Carter has been spotted in South Beach multiple times over the past few weeks, hanging out with his agent Drew Rosenhaus. And if you think that's just a vacation, you haven't been paying attention to the defensive tackle market.
The Market Has Exploded
Jaelan Phillips just signed for $30 million per year — and he's coming off shoulder concerns. Trey Hendrickson got $28 million. These are edge rushers, not interior linemen. But the precedent they set ripples through every defensive contract negotiation in the league. If edge rushers are getting $28-30 million, what does a 24-year-old interior pass rusher with Pro Bowl-caliber talent command?
The answer is north of $35 million. Probably closer to $40 million.
Why Carter Has All the Leverage
The Eagles will almost certainly pick up Carter's fifth-year option at $29 million. But that's just the floor. Carter's camp knows several things: the salary cap is rising every year, the defensive tackle market is thin on elite talent, and Philadelphia has already invested in Carter as a cornerstone piece. Letting him walk would be admitting the entire defensive rebuild strategy was a mistake.
Carter also watched the Eagles let Josh Sweat walk for $19 million last year — only to watch the edge market jump to $30 million twelve months later. If Rosenhaus is advising patience, it's because every week that passes without a deal is a week the market moves further in Carter's direction.
The 2025 Season Complicates Everything
Here's the wrinkle: Carter didn't have his best year. There were games — the 49ers playoff loss being the most glaring — where he was invisible. The Eagles need Carter playing like the 2024 version of himself, the one who was arguably the best interior defender in football. If he shows up in 2026 looking like the 2025 version, the Eagles might have buyer's remorse before the ink dries.
What Happens Next
The Eagles will pick up the option. Carter will bet on himself for one more season. And by March 2027, the conversation won't be about $40 million — it'll be about $45 million and whether the Eagles can afford to keep their entire defensive core together. The clock is ticking on this window, and Rosenhaus knows exactly how to play it.
Enjoying this article?
JAKIB members get premium articles, ad-free shows, exclusive content, and community access. Starting at $4.99/mo.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Paying 4 Stars and Praying: Is Howie Roseman's Strategy a Winning Formula?
Paying 4 Stars and Praying: Is Howie Roseman's Strategy a Winning Formula?
The Eagles are set to lock up four defensive stars to massive deals totaling $130 million. The other seven starters will be replacement-level. Can it work?
Could Sam Darnold Have Won a Super Bowl With the Eagles? The Numbers Say Yes
Could Sam Darnold Have Won a Super Bowl With the Eagles? The Numbers Say Yes
Sam Darnold has thrown for 8,300 yards and 60-plus touchdowns over the last two seasons. The question isn't whether he's good — it's whether Jalen Hurts is better enough to justify the price tag.
The Eagles Have Downgraded at Nearly Every Position Since the Super Bowl
The Eagles Have Downgraded at Nearly Every Position Since the Super Bowl
Thirteen months after winning it all, the Eagles defense looks worse at edge, interior D-line, safety, and cornerback. Only nose tackle and nickel have improved.
The Eagles QB Room Overhaul Nobody's Talking About: McKee, Dalton & Parks Frazier
The Eagles QB Room Overhaul Nobody's Talking About: McKee, Dalton & Parks Frazier
Tanner McKee could be traded for a conditional third. Andy Dalton is the new veteran presence. Parks Frazier is the QB coach. It's a complete teardown behind Jalen Hurts.
Where Does the Jalen Carter Extension Actually Stand? Here's What We Know
Where Does the Jalen Carter Extension Actually Stand? Here's What We Know
Both sides are working on a deal. Drew Rosenhaus wants $40M per year. The Eagles are targeting $35M. The shoulder is the wild card nobody wants to talk about.
Eagles Have 11 Players With Over $25M in Dead Money — The Numbers Are Staggering
Eagles Have 11 Players With Over $25M in Dead Money — The Numbers Are Staggering
Jalen Hurts at $139M, AJ Brown at $76M, and nine more players north of $25M in dead money. The most expensive offense in NFL history finished 27th. That disconnect demands accountability.