Jaelan Phillips vs. Bradley Chubb: The Eagles Edge Rusher Decision That Will Define This Offseason

The Eagles have been chasing an elite pass rusher for two years. They tried to trade for Myles Garrett at the deadline. They traded for Jaelan Phillips midseason from Miami. The message is crystal clear: this organization knows it needs a game-wrecking edge defender to complement Jalen Carter and Jordan Davis on that defensive line. The question heading into free agency is simple — do you pay Jaelan Phillips top dollar, or do you pivot to Bradley Chubb at a fraction of the cost?

The answer should be obvious. And it's not Phillips.

The Phillips Problem

Let's start with what Jaelan Phillips is: a talented, athletic edge rusher with legitimate pass-rush ability. Now let's talk about what he isn't: proven, healthy, or worth $23 million per year. Phillips had five sacks in 2025 — three with Miami before the trade, two with the Eagles in eight games. His career total sits at 28 sacks over four seasons. That's solid, not spectacular. And it comes with a medical file that would make an insurance underwriter nervous.

Two significant injuries have already cost Phillips chunks of playing time. His agent, Drew Rosenhaus, is going to shop him around the league looking for the biggest possible payday. And that's fine — that's what agents do. But should Howie Roseman be the one writing that check? Absolutely not.

At $23-25 million per year, you're paying Phillips like a top-10 edge rusher. He hasn't played like one. You're paying for potential, and in the NFL, potential means you haven't done it yet.

The Chubb Case

Now look at Bradley Chubb. Career: 48 sacks in 90 games. He put up 8.5 sacks in 2025 playing 17 games. He's been more productive, he's healthier recently, and — here's the kicker — he's going to cost significantly less than Phillips on the open market.

But the real ace in the hole? Chubb already knows Vic Fangio's defensive system. He played under Fangio in Denver. He knows the scheme, the terminology, the expectations. There's no learning curve. You plug him in on day one and he's productive immediately. In what might be Fangio's final season as Eagles defensive coordinator, you want a guy who can maximize that system from the jump.

Chubb is cheaper. Chubb is healthier. Chubb is as productive or more productive than Phillips. Chubb knows Fangio's defense. What exactly is the debate here?

The Money Matters

The Eagles have roughly $13 million in effective cap space right now with 61 players on the roster. They've got $48 million in dead cap. This is not a team that can afford to throw stupid money at a player with an inconsistent track record. Every dollar matters this offseason.

Jalen Carter needs a new deal. Jordan Davis needs a new deal. Nakobe Dean is a priority to retain. You can't pay everyone, so you need to be strategic about where the money goes. Signing Chubb at $15-17 million instead of Phillips at $23-25 million gives you an extra $8 million to address other positions. That's a CB2 signing. That's a safety. That's depth on the offensive line.

What Howie Should Do

Here's the play: let Phillips walk. Thank him for his service, wish him well in Tennessee or Jacksonville where some desperate team will overpay him. Then go sign Bradley Chubb to a two-year deal in the $15-17 million range. Pair him with Jalen Carter, Jordan Davis, and Nolan Smith as a rotational pass rusher.

That defensive line — Carter, Davis, Chubb, with Nolan Smith as your specialty pass rusher — is terrifying. And it doesn't break the bank. It leaves you room to address the CB2 position, potentially retain Nakobe Dean, and still have flexibility for the draft.