Paying 4 Stars and Praying: Is Howie Roseman's Strategy a Winning Formula?
The Eagles are set to lock up four defensive stars to massive deals totaling $130 million. The other seven starters will be replacement-level. Can it work?
The JAKIB Staff
contributor
The Eagles' roster-building strategy has crystallized into something very specific: lock up four defensive stars and fill the remaining seven starting spots with minimum-salary players and mid-round draft picks.
Quinyon Mitchell. Jalen Carter. Jordan Davis. Cooper DeJean. Those four names represent the future of Philadelphia's defense — and potentially $130 million in annual salary.
The Math Problem
Let's run the numbers. Mitchell will command around $30 million per year. Carter is looking at $40 million after the market explosion. Davis is already at $26 million. DeJean will be in the $28-30 million range when his time comes. That's $130 million committed to four defensive players. Add the offensive side — Hurts, Barkley, the offensive line, DeVonta Smith — and you're well over $400 million in commitments. The salary cap next year is $380 million.
Something has to give.
The New England Counter-Argument
The Patriots dynasty was built on the opposite philosophy. Bill Belichick let Wes Welker walk. He traded Randy Moss, Richard Seymour, and Logan Mankins. He sent Chandler Jones to Arizona rather than pay top dollar. Gronkowski got shipped to Tampa when he wouldn't take a pay cut. New England believed in the unit over the individual — and they won six Super Bowls doing it.
The Eagles are going the other direction. They're betting that four elite talents, surrounded by replacement-level teammates, can be a championship defense.
Where It Gets Dangerous
The 2024 Super Bowl defense had almost nobody on big money. Sweat was the only significant contract. Carter, Davis, DeJean, Mitchell — all on rookie deals. Bond was cheap. Slay and Gardner-Johnson were the only veterans with real contracts. That roster flexibility is what allowed the defense to be historically great.
Now the Eagles are flipping the script. Instead of eleven solid pieces, they'll have four stars and seven question marks. History says that's a recipe for a 9-8 team, not a Super Bowl contender.
The Draft Is the Pressure Valve
If this strategy has any chance of working, the Eagles have to nail every draft pick and every bargain free agent signing. There's zero margin for error. Bryce Huff was a cautionary tale — one whiff at $19 million and the whole house of cards wobbles. The 2026 draft, particularly at offensive tackle, might be the most important of the Roseman era.
Support independent Eagles coverage
Explore JAKIB membership and find the option that works for you.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Jalen Carter's Next Step Is Consistency, Not More Talent
Jalen Carter already owns the talent, production and contract of a franchise defensive tackle. His next challenge is making disruption routine enough that every opponent has to build its protection plan around him for four quarters.
Why A.J. Brown's Eagles Exit Still Feels Unfinished
A.J. Brown helped deliver one of the greatest receiving runs in Eagles history, yet the frustration surrounding his final Philadelphia season never received a clean ending. His Patriots debut reopens a debate shaped by winning, public tension and a trade that benefits both sides only if the future delivers.
Why the Eagles Still Need an Answer Behind DeVonta Smith
DeVonta Smith can handle a featured role, but coverage tilted toward him will test every receiver around him. Dontayvion Wicks or Makai Lemon needs to become a credible answer before defenses can compress Philadelphia's passing game.
Makai Lemon Faces a Midseason Test in the Eagles' Receiver Room
The Eagles can be patient with most of their rookie class, but Makai Lemon faces a different clock. Philadelphia needs him to earn a useful role by midseason so defenses cannot devote every answer to DeVonta Smith.
What Jalen Hurts Must Prove Before His Next Eagles Contract
Jalen Hurts' next contract decision should turn on whether he drives Philadelphia's offense when the supporting formula breaks. The Eagles also have to preserve room for the young defensive core that can define their next championship window.
How the Eagles' Contract Squeeze Will Shape Their Next Super Bowl Window
Philadelphia's young stars and established offensive core create both a championship opportunity and an approaching contract squeeze. The Eagles must protect the right foundation while continuing to develop affordable contributors around it.