The Eagles Have One Shot at Pick 23: Here's Why They Can't Afford to Get It Wrong
With Lane Johnson turning 36 and the edge rush still incomplete after free agency, the Eagles face a fork-in-the-road decision at pick 23. Offensive tackle or edge rusher — one of these positions demands Round 1 capital, and waiting could be catastrophic.
The Eagles Have One Shot at Pick 23: Here's Why They Can't Afford to Get It Wrong
The Philadelphia Eagles don't have the luxury of patience at pick 23. Not this year. Not with Lane Johnson's body telling a story his competitiveness won't admit, and not with a pass rush that added Arnold Ebiketie on a one-year deal and called it progress.
Let's be honest about where this roster stands heading into the 2026 NFL Draft: the Eagles are a legitimate Super Bowl contender with two glaring holes that could torpedo the whole thing. Offensive tackle and edge rusher aren't just needs — they're ticking time bombs. And the clock on both is louder than anyone in the NovaCare Complex wants to acknowledge.
The Lane Johnson Problem Nobody Wants to Say Out Loud
Lane Johnson was born on May 8, 1990. He turns 36 this spring. That's not a typo.
The man is a Philadelphia legend — a two-time Super Bowl champion, one of the best right tackles of his generation, and the emotional backbone of this offensive line for over a decade. But last season told a story the stats alone can't capture. Johnson missed the Eagles' final eight games, including the entire playoff run. Eight games. For a team with championship aspirations, that's not a blip — that's a structural vulnerability.
Johnson came back for 2026 because he's a warrior. But "year-to-year mode" is front office code for "we need a succession plan yesterday." And right now, the Eagles don't have one. Fred Johnson filled in admirably, but admirably isn't the standard when you're trying to protect Jalen Hurts in January football. The margin for error on this offensive line is razor-thin, and pretending otherwise is fantasy.
Blake Miller out of Clemson keeps showing up in mock drafts to Philadelphia at 23 for a reason. The 6-foot-7 All-ACC right tackle is the prototypical Howie Roseman offensive lineman — massive frame, technical foundation, and the kind of upside that screams "franchise right tackle for the next decade." Multiple draft analysts, including PennLive and Joel Klatt, have connected Miller to the Eagles as the logical Johnson successor. He wouldn't need to start Day 1. He could learn behind Johnson for a season, then step in seamlessly. That's the dream scenario.
But here's the problem: dreams require the board to cooperate.
The Edge Rush Is Still Incomplete
Signing Arnold Ebiketie was smart. It was also insufficient.
Ebiketie brings 16.5 career sacks from his time in Atlanta, including six in 2024 despite starting just two games. He's a rotational pass rusher on a one-year prove-it deal. That's a depth addition, not a solution. The Eagles' edge rush still lacks a true difference-maker who can win one-on-one against elite offensive tackles in high-leverage situations.
This is where Keldric Faulk from Auburn enters the conversation. At 6-6 and 276 pounds, Faulk is the kind of physical specimen that makes defensive coordinators drool. Dane Brugler ranks him as the 15th-best prospect in the entire draft. The Athletic's beat writer mock had him falling to the Eagles at 23, and if that happens, the value would be almost impossible to pass up.
But Faulk's college production tells a more complicated story — just two sacks last season at Auburn. The tools are elite. The tape shows flashes of dominance. But you're betting on projection over production, which is always a gamble in the first round. The Eagles would essentially be saying, "We trust Vic Fangio to unlock this guy." And honestly? With Fangio's track record of developing pass rushers, that might be a bet worth making.
So What Should the Eagles Actually Do?
Here's where I'll take a position that might get me yelled at in the WIP comments: the Eagles need to go offensive tackle at 23.
Edge rusher is important. Nobody's arguing otherwise. But the offensive tackle class has a narrower window of certainty. The top prospects come with question marks around consistency, measurables, and polish. Once that first wave of tackles comes off the board, the drop-off is steep. You're looking at developmental projects and Day 3 gambles. At edge rusher, the class is deeper — quality pass rushers will still be available in Round 2 and even into Round 3.
The math is simple: you can find a competent edge rusher on Day 2. You probably can't find a franchise right tackle there. Not in this class. Not with the uncertainty that exists beyond the top tier.
Lane Johnson has earned the right to retire on his own terms. But the Eagles owe it to Jalen Hurts — and to themselves — to make sure that retirement doesn't leave a crater in the offensive line. The best organizations plan for transitions before they become emergencies. Right now, Philadelphia has a window to do exactly that.
The Bigger Picture
The Eagles have 24 players entering the final year of their contracts in 2026. Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean need extensions in 2027. The A.J. Brown situation remains unresolved. Dallas Goedert just re-signed but is 31. Saquon Barkley is 29 and has generated 3,700 yards of offense since joining Philly, but Father Time is undefeated.
This isn't a roster in crisis. It's a roster at an inflection point. The decisions Howie Roseman makes over the next month — starting with pick 23 — will determine whether this championship window stays open for three more years or starts closing by 2027.
The draft is one month away. The Eagles have one first-round pick. One shot to address two critical needs. And in a class where waiting at either position carries real risk, the margin for error is nonexistent.
Philadelphia doesn't need a home run at 23. They need a sure thing. And right now, that sure thing wears an offensive tackle's number.
Enjoying this article?
JAKIB members get premium articles, ad-free shows, exclusive content, and community access. Starting at $4.99/mo.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
The AJ Brown Domino Effect: How One Trade Reshapes the Eagles' Entire Draft Strategy
The AJ Brown Domino Effect: How One Trade Reshapes the Eagles' Entire Draft Strategy
The Eagles appear headed toward trading AJ Brown after June 1, and the ripple effects will transform their approach at pick 23 and beyond. Here's the full breakdown of how one move changes everything.
Pick 23 Will Define the Eagles' Next Era: Why the OT vs. Edge Debate Matters More Than You Think
Pick 23 Will Define the Eagles' Next Era: Why the OT vs. Edge Debate Matters More Than You Think
The Eagles hold nine picks in the 2026 NFL Draft, but none matters more than No. 23. With Lane Johnson's clock ticking and edge rusher still unfinished, Howie Roseman's first-round decision could reshape Philadelphia's championship window for years.
The Eagles Have 24 Players in Contract Years — Here's How Howie Should Prioritize Them
The Eagles Have 24 Players in Contract Years — Here's How Howie Should Prioritize Them
With 24 players entering the final year of their deals, the Eagles face a salary cap chess match that will define the next three years. Here's the priority list Howie Roseman needs to follow.
Eagles 2026 Position Report Cards: Offensive Line
Eagles 2026 Position Report Cards: Offensive Line
Philadelphia's offensive line returns all five starters in 2026 but faces critical questions about depth, Tyler Steen's development, and how a new scheme under Sean Mannion will reshape the unit's identity.
Saquon Barkley Is Not Derek Henry — And It's Not Close
Saquon Barkley Is Not Derek Henry — And It's Not Close
Eagles fans love Saquon Barkley. But comparing him to Derek Henry? The stats don't back it up. Henry is a generational throwback running back. Barkley had one phenomenal year.
Why Lane Johnson Will Be Harder to Replace Than AJ Brown
Why Lane Johnson Will Be Harder to Replace Than AJ Brown
Wide receivers are dime a dozen in the modern NFL. A Hall of Fame right tackle? That's a once-in-a-generation find. Here's why Lane Johnson's departure will hurt more than AJ Brown's.