Eagles 2026 Position Report Cards: Quarterback
Jalen Hurts delivered an elite season in 2025, but the Eagles' quarterback room looks different heading into 2026. We grade the position group and assess what comes next.
The JAKIB Staff
contributor
This is Part 1 of a 10-part series grading every Philadelphia Eagles position group heading into the 2026 season. We start where every evaluation should: under center.
The Eagles' quarterback situation entering 2026 is simultaneously one of the most stable and most scrutinized in the NFL. Jalen Hurts is the franchise. That much is settled. But the room behind him has undergone significant change this offseason, and the depth chart tells a story about where Philadelphia's priorities really lie.
Jalen Hurts: The Unquestioned Franchise
There is no quarterback controversy in Philadelphia. Jalen Hurts proved that emphatically in 2025 with one of the most complete seasons of his career. His command of the offense under the new coordinator was a revelation — more decisive in the pocket, sharper on timing routes, and still the most dangerous rushing quarterback in the game when he needed to be.
Hurts' ability to elevate in big moments has become his calling card. The playoff performances silenced the remaining doubters — at least the reasonable ones. His connection with A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith continues to be one of the most lethal receiver duos in football, and he's learned when to check down to Saquon Barkley rather than forcing a big play.
The contract remains massive — Hurts' cap hit is among the highest in the league — but production has matched the price tag. When you're paying a quarterback top dollar, you need top-five play. Hurts has delivered that, and the Eagles' offensive identity flows through his unique skill set.
Behind Hurts: The Depth Chart Shift
Here's where the picture gets more complicated. Sam Howell is gone — signed with the Cowboys in free agency, a move that raised some eyebrows in Philly. Howell was a capable backup who knew the system, and losing him to a division rival stings even if it was purely a business decision.
That leaves Tanner McKee as the primary backup, and this is where the Eagles need to be honest with themselves. McKee flashed in preseason action and has the physical tools — the arm talent, the size, the pocket awareness — but he's still largely unproven in meaningful regular season minutes. If Hurts goes down for any stretch, the margin for error shrinks dramatically.
The Eagles may address the QB3 spot through the draft or undrafted free agency, but the expectation is clear: Hurts plays 17 games. The entire roster construction is built on that assumption. Whether that's a strength or a vulnerability depends on your perspective.
The Sean Mannion Factor
Any quarterback evaluation in 2026 has to account for the coaching change. Sean Mannion took over as offensive coordinator after the Eagles moved on from the previous staff, and his influence on Hurts' development cannot be overlooked. The early returns suggest a scheme that plays to Hurts' strengths — more play-action concepts, a simplified pre-snap read system, and a willingness to let Hurts improvise when the pocket breaks down.
Mannion's background as a former quarterback gives him credibility in the room. The relationship between an OC and his starting quarterback is the most important dynamic on any roster, and all indications point to Hurts and Mannion being firmly on the same page heading into Year 1 together.
The Grade: A-
The starting position is an A+. There might be five quarterbacks in the NFL you'd take over Hurts on a given Sunday, and even that list is debatable. The man has proven he can carry a team deep into January and beyond.
The depth is what keeps this from a straight A. Losing Howell to Dallas without adding a proven veteran backup is a calculated risk. McKee could be the answer, but he hasn't been tested under fire yet. If Hurts misses even two games, the Eagles' Super Bowl window could slam shut in a hurry.
The new OC pairing adds intrigue and upside. If Mannion can unlock another gear in Hurts — particularly in the intermediate passing game where he's historically been inconsistent — this grade goes up. The ceiling is a top-three quarterback season. The floor, assuming health, is still top-ten.
What to Watch This Offseason
Keep an eye on the draft. The Eagles hold a late first-round pick, and while quarterback isn't a need, the team may look at a developmental arm in the middle rounds if the value is there. Howie Roseman has never been afraid to stockpile assets at premium positions, and adding a young quarterback to sit behind Hurts and compete with McKee would be smart roster building.
The bigger storyline is Hurts' continued evolution. At 27, he's entering what should be his prime years. The weapons around him are elite. The offensive line remains among the best in football. The defense can win games on its own. Everything is built for Hurts to take the next step — and this quarterback room's grade in September could look very different from the one we're giving today.
Next up in the series: Running Back. With Saquon Barkley leading the charge and a retooled backfield behind him, there's plenty to unpack.
Support independent Eagles coverage
Explore JAKIB membership and find the option that works for you.
The JAKIB Staff
AI-powered content assistant for JAKIB Sports. Articles generated from show transcripts and Eagles coverage.
Related Articles
Hollywood Brown's Reported Exit Closes the Eagles' Veteran Receiver Bridge
Hollywood Brown’s reported departure would close a veteran bridge that never gained a dependable role. The next Eagles receiver plan has to make development and immediate responsibilities fit together.
Jordan Davis Trade Gives the Eagles Premium Picks and a New Defensive Decision
The Eagles agreed to send Jordan Davis to Jacksonville for a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-round pick, pending a physical. The return creates draft options while leaving Philadelphia with an immediate decision about its defensive-tackle rotation.
Caleb Williams’ Improvement Starts With the Structure Around Him
Caleb Williams completed 70.9 percent of his passes across five starts through Week 8. Protection, run-game connections and continuity offer a framework for examining the improvement without taking credit away from the quarterback or treating a small sample as causal proof.
Saquon Barkley’s Value in an Eagles Rebuild Goes Beyond His Stat Line
Saquon Barkley’s leadership belongs in the Eagles’ roster discussion alongside his football role and the opportunities available to younger backs. His contract already runs through 2028, and long-term value does not settle game-day medical questions.
The Eagles’ Backup Quarterback Problem Is Bigger Than One Bad Start
The Eagles invested in backup quarterbacks. The harder question is whether practice work, scheme fit and a usable replacement plan prepared the offense to function when the quarterback changed.
The Eagles Cannot Develop an Offense on a One-Year Coaching Clock
The Eagles should judge Sean Mannion and the quarterbacks by how quickly they solve recurring defensive problems. Continuity earns its value through clearer answers, not another year on the calendar.
Latest from JAKIB Sports
View all articles →The Eagles Have to Tackle Pittsburgh’s Short Passing Game
November 20, 2026
Pittsburgh Will Test How Quickly the Eagles Can Identify a Free Rusher
November 20, 2026
Where Would Jihaad Campbell Fit in a Four-Man Eagles Front?
November 20, 2026
DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks Could Open Up First Down for Joe Milton
November 20, 2026
